Skip to content

Welcome to our new online store! We are currently updating our inventory. Free U.S. shipping on all orders!

Vintage Sports Cards
Bobble Heads
Unopened Boxes & Packs
Modern Cards
Rookie Cards
Football Cards
Signed Sports Memorabilia
Yearbooks Programs plus
Complete Sets
Team Sets

Cape May Sports Memorabilia

Account

Your cart is empty

Have an account? Log in to check out faster.

Continue shopping

Vintage Sports Cards

Pre 1960 Cards
1960s Cards
1970s Cards
1980s Cards
HOF Cards
Star Cards
Team Set
Complete Sets
Tobacco Cards

Unopened Boxes & Packs

Signed Sports Memorabilia

Yearbooks Programs plus

Home / Pre-1960 Cards

Pre-1960 Cards

Skip to results list

Active filters:

Availability

In stock
Out of stock

Price

$

to

$

The highest price is $450.00

Clear

1 item

Sort

Sort Most relevant

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

Column grid

Column grid

Filter

Active filters:

Availability

In stock
Out of stock

Price

$

to

$

The highest price is $450.00

Sort

Sort Most relevant

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

1958 Topps 487 Mickey Mantle All Star (Sharp Card)

1958 Topps 487 Mickey Mantle All Star (Sharp Card)

1958 Topps 487 Mickey Mantle All Star (Sharp Card)

$450.00

Sale price $450.00 Regular price

Cape May Sports Memorabilia

201-306-0076

mike@capemaysportsmemorabilia.com

Shop Collectibles Shop Collectibles

Vintage Sports Cards
Bobble Heads
Unopened Boxes & Packs
Modern Cards
Rookie Cards
Football Cards
Signed Sports Memorabilia
Yearbooks Programs plus
Complete Sets
Team Sets

About Us About Us

Dealer/Wholesale
Sell your collection
Contact

Special Requests

Is there a collectible piece of sports memorabilia you’d like to own that you don’t see on this website?

Please contact us. We may have it!

© 2026 Cape May Sports Memorabilia

Privacy policy

Search

Search

Products

(TWO) 2025 Panini Score Football 90 Ct. Blaster Box (unopened)

(TWO) 2025 Panini Score Football 90 Ct. Blaster Box (unopened)

$44.99

Regular price Sale price $44.99
1909 Piedmont T206 Al Burch Batting Brooklyn SGC 1.0

1909 Piedmont T206 Al Burch Batting Brooklyn SGC 1.0

$125.00

Regular price Sale price $125.00
1909 Piedmont T206 Art Devlin NY Nat'l SGC 1.0

1909 Piedmont T206 Art Devlin NY Nat'l SGC 1.0

$100.00

Regular price Sale price $100.00
1909 Piedmont T206 Beals Becker Boston Nat'l SGC 1.0

1909 Piedmont T206 Beals Becker Boston Nat'l SGC 1.0

$75.00

Regular price Sale price $75.00

×

Please wait...

Make An Offer

null

Name

Email

Quantity

Offer

Message

null

SKU: